Comparing: The Darwin Elevator and Boneshaker

Immunes, and steampunk, and sci-fi… oh my!

I lucked out on my honeymoon reads and picked some amazing books. If you’re looking for new hard-hitting science fiction OR glorious steampunk to read… look no further. 

The Darwin Elevator by Jason M. Hough (who you can follow on Twitter here: https://twitter.com/JasonMHough )

Flash-forward to the 23rd century. The last city on Earth? Darwin, Australia (my money was on Cary, NC, but whatever). An alien plague has decimated the population, transforming the afflicted into zombies, referred to in the story as “subs”. However, the same aliens that delivered the plague also delivered refuge in the form of a space elevator that emits an aura to keep the disease at bay. The main character, Skyler Luiken, happens to carry a rare immunity to the disease. He and his crew are scavengers that conduct missions out beyond the aura’s edge, collecting resources for the ragged heap of humanity back in Darwin.

Boneshaker by Cherie Priest (who you can follow on Twitter here: https://twitter.com/cmpriest)

Flash-backward to the 1800’s. An Alaskan gold-rush brings wealth to the Pacific Northwest, but it also delivers calamity. Leviticus Blue creates the Boneshaker, a digging machine that creates chaos in downtown Seattle, releasing a horrible Blight that transforms the affected into walking “rotters”. The story takes place more than a decade later, as the widow of Levitics Blue and her son try to live life under the curse of their past. Ezekiel’s frustration with his father’s legacy eventually leads him into the Blight-ruined city, forcing Briar to follow after him. Inside the city? The walking dead, dangerous overlords, and a host of deeper, more hidden dangers await.

So, how do they compare?

1. First, in the use of the undead. Both authors have a great sense of what they want their undead creatures to be. In Boneshaker, Priest tends to use her rotters as an element of sheer terror. She does a wonderful job of building the horror of any scene through consistent descriptions and, I noticed, the noise the “rotters” make. It’s terrifying. In The Darwin Elevator, Hough definitely provides suspense and fear through his zombies, but there is the added mystery of the “SUBS” disease. Why did the aliens deliver this plague? And why is the Aura suddenly not protecting against it?

2. Steampunk vs. Science Fiction- I’ve always enjoyed science fiction, but am not a “hard” science fiction reader. Some of the mechanical descriptions of how a space station works… they sound… mechanical to me. Hough does a good job of enlivening his plot through some pretty cool futuristic devices, but I have to admit that STEAMPUNK took the cake for me. I’m not sure how far I’ve dipped my toes into the genre, but Priest really caught my intention with some clever inventions. And who can complain about zepplins crashing into Blight-infested streets?! 

3. Plot development is so crucial. So… the other book I read this week was a little book called Divergent. It may or may not be super popular right now, and I may or may not have watched the movie last night. Here’s the thing: Divergent does not really have a great plot. We have a front loaded book that spends about 300 pages on “initiation” (remember, the Hunger Games wrapped that section of the book up in about 30 or 40 pages) and then a gauntlet chase over the last 100 pages that, at points, doesn’t even allow us the proper time to mourn or celebrate or digest. The only reason I noticed this about Divergent? Because I read Boneshaker and The Darwin Elevator right before it. BOTH of these books do a wonderful job of leading us through suspense-filled action. Both books raise the stakes. Both books provide a certain building to a certain climax to a certain resolution. What I felt the Divergent lacked, both Priest and Hough pull off in a fantastic fashion.

So… what didn’t I like?

1. In The Darwin Elevator, I did notice that some of the important moments took place “off-stage” as it were. This may be a Hollywood, cinematic syndrome on my part… but some of the most impacting moments the narrator experiences are more of a “collateral damage” feel. He’s reacting to the damage report, and not always present in the moment of loss or pain.

2. RUSSELL BLACKFIELD – Which made him the perfect antagonist. Man, that guy is SUCH a tool.

3. In Boneshaker, I actually had a hard time connecting with Zeke. Priest does a wonderful job of making his character somewhat petulant. He complains quickly, he’s sort of the “annoying brother” at times… While it made sense for his character, and is sometimes a likeable thing to see faults in our protagonists, I found him hard to fully identify with. I LOVED Briar Wilkes though. She’s tough as nails, consistent, and really easy to get behind as a sympathetic character.

 

I strongly urge you to go out an pick up BOTH of these books. If you’re a TEACHER, I’d say that either of these could be added to your classroom library. Boneshaker might be a little more appropriate for the 9th-10th grade audience. I’d say that The Darwin Elevator includes a few scenes and words that may be a little too provocative, but I think the work as a whole covers up any possible complaint there. In matters of “appropriateness”, I tend to look at the protagonist as a model. Is Skyler Luiken someone that I’d want my students to act like? And there are several scenes, between him and authority figures, between him and women, that really make him distinctly worthy of that kind of role. Having a character like that should make it easy for students to dismiss the inappropriate thoughts of Russell Blackfield as… inappropriate.

Either way, happy reading!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s